What happens when business ethics no longer counts in the FT50 journal list?
Published here:
The removal of the Journal of Business Ethics from the Financial Times’ influential FT50 list is more than a change in journal rankings. As Salim Moussa argues, it raises uncomfortable questions about what business schools value, what kinds of research they reward, and whether their commitment to responsible management is matched by their academic evaluation systems.
In April 2026, the Financial Times (FT) made its first major revision to its influential FT50 journal list in a decade. Three journals disappeared: Journal of Business Ethics , Human Relations , and Organization Studies . They were replaced by Academy of Management Annals , American Sociological Review , and Psychological Science .
At first glance, this might look like a routine adjustment to an academic journal “quality” list. But the removal of the Journal of Business Ethics (JBE) deserves particular attention. For years, it was the only journal in the FT50 specifically dedicated to business ethics, corporate responsibility and sustainability. Its exclusion raises a question that extends well beyond the fate of one journal: what does contemporary management academia consider worthy of recognition?
More than a journal-list adjustment?
The FT explained its decision in terms of influence and relevance, referring to the academic standing, impact factors and institutional contributions associated with the newly included journals. These are legitimate considerations for a publication list designed to contribute to business school rankings. The FT is not obliged to ensure that every research domain has a dedicated journal represented.
Yet, the composition of the revised list has consequences worth examining. The three removed journals represented distinctive intellectual traditions, including business ethics, organisational studies and critical approaches to organisations. Their replacements bring different disciplinary and methodological orientations into the FT50.
The issue is not that the newly included journals lack scholarly merit. Nor does the removal of JBE mean that ethics and sustainability research will disappear from the remaining journals. It is, rather, that the FT50 has lost its only dedicated outlet for this body of scholarship.
This distinction matters. Research by Rodenburg and colleagues found that 48.1% of FT50 articles addressing one or more of the United Nations’ Sustainable Development Goals in 2019 were published in JBE. This finding illustrates the journal’s distinctive contribution to the representation of socially relevant research within the FT50 list.[1]
Its removal therefore creates a symbolic gap, even if research on sustainability and responsibility continues to find its way into other prestigious outlets.
The contradiction at the heart of business education
There is an uncomfortable paradox here.
Business schools increasingly emphasise sustainability, corporate social responsibility, stakeholder capitalism, ethical leadership and societal impact. Responsible management education has become an important part of institutional strategies, curricula and accreditation discussions. Universities and business schools are expected to prepare graduates who can address not only economic challenges but also environmental and social responsibilities.
At the same time, academic careers in many business schools remain closely tied to publication in a small number of highly ranked journals. The FT50, alongside other journal lists, can influence recruitment, promotion, research funding and institutional reputation. What happens when the journals that receive the greatest institutional recognition do not fully reflect the values that business schools publicly promote?
The removal of JBE could widen this gap between institutional rhetoric and evaluation practice. It potentially sends a message that research on ethics and sustainability is less central to elite management scholarship than other forms of research.
This is not an argument that researchers should publish in particular journals simply because of their subject matter. It is an argument that the institutional recognition of research should not systematically disadvantage questions that are central to the social responsibilities of business.[2]
Rankings do not simply measure academic value
The deeper problem concerns the power of journal lists themselves.
These lists are often presented as instruments for identifying and measuring academic excellence. But they also help construct the very hierarchies they claim to measure. Inclusion in a prestigious list can enhance a journal’s visibility, reputation and attractiveness to authors. It can also influence how researchers, institutions and doctoral students perceive the value of different research topics.
This creates a potentially self-reinforcing process. Journals receive recognition because they are considered prestigious, while that recognition further strengthens their prestige. Researchers respond to the incentives created by these hierarchies, and institutions incorporate them into evaluation systems.
Consequently, journal lists may influence not only where academics publish but also, indirectly, what they choose to investigate . For an early-career researcher working on sustainability, business ethics or corporate responsibility, the perceived career value of a publication outlet matters. If dedicated outlets for these topics lose their standing within influential evaluation systems, some researchers may reconsider the risks associated with pursuing such questions.[3]
It is important to emphasise that we do not yet have evidence that the 2026 revision has changed research agendas or discouraged scholars from pursuing responsible management topics. These are potential consequences, not demonstrated effects. Nevertheless, the incentive mechanisms through which such effects could emerge deserve serious attention.
Who decides what research excellence means?
The FT is entitled to develop a list that serves its own business school rankings. But universities and business schools should not automatically treat that list as a comprehensive definition of academic quality.
The FT50 is not the only journal-ranking system, nor is it a universal measure of research excellence. Different institutions and national research systems use different evaluation frameworks. The influence of the FT50 varies accordingly.
The responsibility for how the list is used ultimately rests with academic institutions themselves. Business schools should therefore ask whether their evaluation systems adequately recognise intellectual diversity, interdisciplinary research, societal relevance and contributions to public policy. Citation performance and methodological rigour remain important, but they do not exhaust the meaning of valuable scholarship.
Research on climate change, inequality, corporate misconduct, ethical leadership and sustainable business practices may generate contributions that cannot be fully captured by conventional journal-based indicators. A more pluralistic approach would assess research through a broader set of criteria, including its theoretical contribution, methodological quality, relevance to societal challenges and potential to inform practice and policy.
What do business schools choose to reward?
The removal of JBE from the FT50 should not be interpreted as the end of business ethics research, nor should it diminish the scholarly contributions of the journals added to the list. But, it should prompt a wider discussion about the relationship between academic prestige and societal responsibility.
If business schools genuinely believe that businesses must become more ethical, sustainable and socially responsible, their research evaluation systems should reflect those commitments.
The question is not whether business ethics deserves a guaranteed place in every journal list. It is whether the academic institutions that claim to value responsible management are prepared to recognise and reward the research needed to advance it.
Ultimately, the FT50 controversy reminds us of something fundamental: journal lists do not simply measure academic value. They also shape it. And when the systems that define academic prestige change, we should pay attention not only to which journals enter or leave the list, but also to which forms of knowledge risk losing recognition.
📑This post draws on the author’s article, The FT50’s ethics problem: What the removal of Journal of Business Ethics means for management research , published in Research Evaluation.[4]
This article gives the views of the authors, not the position of LSE Impact or the London School of Economics. You are agreeing with our comment policy when you leave a comment.[5]