← World & context

Rethinking credit ratings for the long term

Published here:

Credit ratings are among the most influential yet underappreciated gatekeepers of global development. Dennis Shen and Moritz Kraemer argue that adopting very long-term perspectives on creditworthiness, a deeper consideration of climate risks and expected-loss methodologies could help ratings mobilise patient capital and make credit ratings not merely a measure of risk, but an instrument for financing long-term development.

Credit ratings are meant to make financial markets safer and more efficient. Yet in some of the world’s most consequential moments, they can do precisely the opposite. A downgrade during a sovereign debt crisis may raise borrowing costs, accelerate capital flight and make restructuring more difficult. Conversely, during repeated phases of exuberance, ratings can validate risks that later prove badly underestimated.

This is not necessarily because credit rating agencies are failing at their assigned task. It may be because the task itself is no longer sufficient.

At an inaugural Hamburg Sustainability Conference , in 2024, former German Chancellor Olaf Scholz identified credit ratings as one area demanding attention to advance the UN’s Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). The world’s main rating agencies are largely products of the past, while financial markets, climate risks and the global economy have changed profoundly.[1][2]

What is required is a more forward-looking conception of credit evaluation, developed around assessments extended over much longer horizons . Such ratings could complement conventional assessments while better capturing the long-term forces shaping credit. By making structural changes and future risks more visible, such ratings could mobilise private capital for long-term investment and align credit assessment more closely with global development goals.[3]

A very long-term horizon could better capture development outcomes

Conventional ratings emphasise historical performance and comparatively short- and medium-term prospects. This can disadvantage economies whose structural transformations take decades to materialise.

Such a stress on the near term engrains today’s global financial architecture within ratings and impedes the transformative changes that may help developing countries to escape the poverty trap. For many, such constraints may be misinterpreted as an inherent bias of the US-based Big 3 credit rating agencies against the global south.[4]

Consider Chad, a landlocked country in Central Africa whose economy remains highly dependent on oil and vulnerable to external and climate-related shocks. Its comparatively low economic development and weak governance may weigh on its conventional rating. But credible progress in governance, oil-revenue management, education and agricultural productivity could enhance its capacity to service debt over several decades. A very long-term rating may capture that potential more fully than a conventional assessment – not by assuming success, but by evaluating its plausibility.

The reverse must also hold. A longer horizon does not guarantee developing countries stronger ratings. Investments can fail, institutions can deteriorate, demographics change and climate shocks can undermine growth. The rating must represent the credibility of a country’s trajectory, not its aspirations.

A rating looking decades ahead asks a novel question

A rating looking decades rather than years ahead asks a profoundly novel question: what may a country’s capacity to repay look like once today’s investments mature? Rather than evaluating development primarily as a source of near-term fiscal pressures, it may more adequately represent the event that well-directed investment expands productive capacity and ultimately strengthens resilience.

Such ratings may prove less cyclical than conventional credit assessments because of a long-run anchor – curtailing a tendency of ratings to fall behind structural developments only to downgrade when economies are under the greatest stress. During boom years, the same long-run perspective may provide a counterweight against excessive optimism.

This would ultimately make ratings more useful for investors. Credit ratings have a responsibility to anchor markets, and not to follow whims. But all too frequently they fail at this. Very long-term ratings could help incentivise the desired forward-looking behaviours, motivate a lengthening of investment horizons and advance patient capital.

To evaluate countries’ long-run trajectories, such ratings may rely on established frameworks – such as the SDGs and the African Union’s Agenda 2063 – as benchmarks for evaluating whether policies and investments are strengthening longer-run economic capacity. Credible progress could help countries improve their credit standing, creating incentives to invest in the institutions and capabilities that underpin sustainable development.[5]

An approach that supports climate and sovereign debt resolution

Climate change exemplifies the value of such an approach. Its fiscal and economic c o nsequences accumulate over decades yet may be inadequately reflected in assessments dominated by nearer-term risks. A longer horizon could make climate exposures, resilience and climate costs more integral to creditworthiness.[6]

A long-term perspective may also advance sovereign debt resolution. Governments facing unsustainable debt may delay restructuring for fear that a downgrade raises borrowing costs or shuts them out of capital markets. Such hesitation can only prolong unsustainable debt burdens, deepen economic damage and enhance creditor losses.

An expected-loss framework, evaluated over such a lengthened horizon, could help distinguish between outcomes. An orderly restructuring that restores solvency and limits ultimate creditor losses may be assessed more favourably than prolonged inaction followed by disorderly default. This would not reward default; it would recognise that timely debt resolution can produce better outcomes for creditors and debtors alike. This could render ratings a part of the solution to sovereign debt crises rather than an obstacle to their resolution.[7]

Such an approach would require novel, transparent methodologies, rigorous disclosures of assumptions and a clear separation between quantitative model outputs and qualitative analyst judgments. Its long-term assessments would need to make uncertainty over such horizons explicit.

Developing countries, such as in Africa, have argued that international ratings do not adequately capture their structural transformations and long-run economic prospects. The Africa Credit Rating Agency (AfCRA), established on 7 October 2026, represents a novel effort in providing an alternative approach for the continent. The experiences of AfCRA will be closely watched.[8]

Very long-term ratings could reshape risk

The objective of very long-term ratings ought to be to complement regional and global initiatives. Whether through the reform of existing approaches or, alternatively, the establishment of a dedicated global long-term agency, a methodology extending the horizons of credit must preserve the qualities that make ratings valuable. Such assessments should be independent without being indifferent to structural change; innovative while avoiding inconsistencies analytically; and forward-looking without becoming speculative. The purpose of such ratings should not be to promote development regardless of risk, but to recognise how credible development can reshape risk itself.

Credit ratings sit at the intersection of sovereign finance, private investment and global development. A truly long-term agency could help markets recognise the difference between today’s constraints and tomorrow’s possibilities.

Credit ratings should do more than measure the world as it is. They should help finance the world as it could be.

This article gives the views of the author, not the position of LSE Business Review or the London School of Economics. You are agreeing with our comment policy when you leave a comment.