← World & context

Half of Europe backs climate policy – only Germany acts on it

Published here:

European sustainability communication is still largely addressed to a single, average citizen. But that average citizen does not exist. New evidence suggests the gap between what Europeans say about climate and what they do is not primarily a problem of conviction or information. Nazife Merve Hamzaoğlu argues that it is a gap in the infrastructure that translates conviction into routine action – and Germany shows that gap can close.

As COP31 rumbles on in Antalya this week, European climate policy faces a question it has never been able to answer cleanly. Opinion polls across the European Union show large and durable majorities in favour of ambitious climate action. Behaviour indicators across the same populations show far more modest change. Each successive COP cycle revives the puzzle. And each successive round of policy design returns, by default, to communication: the need for better messaging , clearer labelling, sharper nudges to close the gap between what Europeans say and what they do.[1][2]

New evidence from the 2024 wave of the Eurobarometer on Europeans’ environmental attitudes suggests that this instinct is misplaced. The gap between attitude and behaviour is real, it is large and it is concentrated in nearly half of the European population. But it is not primarily a gap in conviction or information. It is a gap in the infrastructure and institutions that translate conviction into routine action – and the data show at least one member state where that gap has already closed.[3]

A segmentation of the EU27 public

The analysis uses Special Eurobarometer 550 (N = 26,332, fielded March–April 2024 across all 27 Member States). A latent class analysis on sixteen indicators – covering environmental concern, observed waste-reduction behaviour, willingness to pay for sustainable products, policy support and chemical-risk literacy – produces a five-class description of the EU27 public.[3][4]

The largest class, at 47.1 per cent, combines high environmental concern and the highest support for EU environmental legislation with only moderate behavioural engagement. These are Concerned Policy Supporters: citizens who want the regulation, back the polluter-pays principle and expect public authorities to act, but whose observed practice lags well behind their attitudes. At 20.8 per cent a second class, Comprehensive Eco-Citizens, shows uniformly high engagement across all five domains. A further 14.2 per cent, the Chemically Concerned Pragmatists, hold high concern about chemical hazards and personal health without broader systemic engagement. Only 12.9 per cent are Disengaged. A small residual (4.9 per cent) shows the opposite profile: strong waste-reduction behaviour with only moderate attitudinal commitment.

The structural implication is immediate. European sustainability communication is still largely addressed to a single, average citizen. But that average citizen does not exist. The five segments have qualitatively different profiles, not just different intensities, and an intervention designed for one will reliably misfire against the others.

A gap that is bigger than the literature has treated it

Earlier European segmentation studies have documented the attitude-behaviour gap as a feature of some part of the population – a convinced-but-inactive minority among several other profiles. The 2024 data show something more awkward. Nearly half of EU citizens now occupy precisely this position. They are convinced, they want EU-level regulation and they do not translate their support into practice at anything like the same intensity.[5]

Nor does the usual cost-of-living explanation survive contact with the data. Household economic difficulty is not the dominant predictor of class membership. In fact, respondents reporting the most severe bill-paying difficulties are associated with higher, not lower, Comprehensive Eco-Citizen membership. Education and political views are more strongly associated with where citizens fall across the five segments than their household budget position. That is a descriptive finding, not a causal one – but it displaces a convenient narrative. A simple “Europeans can no longer afford to care about the climate” story does not fit.

What the German case shows

The most interesting finding sits inside the country-stratified estimation. Re-estimating the five-class solution separately on the four largest Member State subsamples (Germany, France, Italy, Spain) recovers the broad structure in three of them. Italy’s dominant segment reproduces the EU pooled pattern most closely, with high concern and moderate behaviour. France and Spain show smaller but still visible attitude-behaviour gaps.

Germany is different in kind. Its dominant class combines high environmental concern (around 94 per cent) with high observed behaviour (around 95 per cent). The gap, in Germany’s largest segment, is effectively zero.

Germany is not an outlier because its citizens care more. It is an outlier because the infrastructure around them has been built, slowly and expensively, to make caring translate into action. Several decades of waste-management investment, deposit-return systems for beverage packaging, visible municipal recycling logistics and extended producer responsibility regimes that pre-date the European Green Deal have made pro-environmental behaviour the path of least resistance, rather than an act of individual commitment against friction. Where contextual facilitation is strong, the attitude-behaviour gap disappears. Where it is weak, no amount of communication closes it.[6]

The lesson for COP31

The practical consequence for COP31, and for the EU climate policy architecture it feeds into, runs against the grain of a decade of behavioural policy discussion. For the Concerned Policy Supporter segment – the half of Europe that already backs climate policy – more information is unlikely to be the binding constraint. These citizens have the attitudes the policy agenda assumes and asks for. What they lack is the physical and institutional infrastructure that makes acting on those attitudes routine.

That reframes several COP-adjacent debates. Climate finance aimed at member states’ infrastructural catch-up is likely to do more to close the attitude-behaviour gap than the next round of consumer-facing communication campaigns. Many green initiatives and infrastructure are not glamorous, and they do not produce the kind of consumer-level behavioural change story that nudge campaigns promise. But the data from Germany suggest they do something that nudges have not yet achieved at scale: they make the attitude-behaviour gap vanish for the majority of citizens.

For the smaller segments – the Chemically Concerned Pragmatists, the Disengaged, the Behavioural-Only Adopters – different combinations of regulation, targeted information and affordability policy apply. A segment-aware policy architecture is slower to design than a single communication campaign. It is also more likely to work.

The temptation at every COP is to treat citizens as the variable that policy has to change. The 2024 segmentation points the other way. Half of Europe’s citizens have already moved. What has not moved, in most EU countries, is the plumbing that would let their support turn into practice. The hard work of COP31, if it is honest about what the data say, is less about persuading Europeans to care and more about building the institutions and infrastructure that let their existing care translate into routine behaviour.

Germany shows this is possible. The rest of the Union has not yet shown it is willing.

This article gives the views of the author, not the position of LSE Business Review or the London School of Economics. You are agreeing with our comment policy when you leave a comment.