← World & context

The blockade of French universities offers an opportunity to radically rethink their purpose

Published here:

Social unrest in France has seen many higher education institutions blockaded. With access limited, Gilles A. Paché argues the blockages offer an opportunity to rethink entrenched teaching practices and build a more resilient model of higher education in which physical attendance is less readily equated with effective learning.

The French university tradition struggles to critically examine its own governance and pedagogical practices. It takes only a few campus closures for established teaching arrangements to falter. Campus blockades, administrative closures, protests and hastily improvised remote instruction have disrupted deeply ingrained routines. Faculty members have had to adapt at short notice: relocating courses, revising teaching materials and finding ways to ensure continuity of learning.

I don’t want to trivialise the blockades or overlook their impact on students and staff, particularly in terms of unequal access to academic resources. Yet the disruptions expose a deeper vulnerability: can difficult circumstances become an opportunity to rethink pedagogical practices? Rather than reflexively restoring the status quo, might it be time to question its limitations and explore more sustainable approaches to teaching, learning and the transmission of knowledge?

Being present is not the same as learning

There is a persistent misconception within academia: to equate physical attendance with pedagogical quality. Being in a classroom does not necessarily mean learning is taking place; likewise, listening to an instructor for two hours guarantees neither attention nor understanding.

Physical presence may facilitate learning, but it does not guarantee it. As John Dewey reminds us, an experience is not inherently educational ; everything depends on what students derive from it and their subsequent ability to apply what they have learned. Michelene Chi and Ruth Wylie’s ICAP framework makes a similar point by distinguishing between passive, active, constructive and interactive forms of cognitive engagement. A student who is physically present but intellectually disengaged is not necessarily better placed to learn than a remote student who is reflecting, producing and interacting.[1][2]

However, the perception that being in the room matters is deeply ingrained. Findings from a study published in the late 2010s indicate that students engaged in active learning achieve better results , even though they sometimes feel they have learned less than those attending traditional lectures. Physical presence is easy to observe; intellectual engagement is far less so. It is therefore tempting to confuse what is visible with what is actually being learned. The issue is not in-person instruction, whose relational benefits are undeniable, but the almost unquestionable status we sometimes accord it.[3]

Beyond the online lecture

The shift to remote learning often reveals a limited conception of pedagogical innovation: take the usual course, launch a video conference and replicate exactly the same session before a mosaic of faces, some attentive, others less so, and some not even visible. The duration, slides, lecture content and structure remain identical; only the setting changes.

Yet, a distinction must be made between thoughtfully designed distance education and ‘ emergency remote teaching ’. Simply transferring an in-person course online is not pedagogical innovation. An emergency, however, can provide an opportunity to devise something different. The Community of Inquiry framework suggests a compelling perspective by highlighting three complementary dimensions of an online learning experience: teaching presence, social presence and cognitive presence.[4][5]

Remote learning does not mean eliminating the pedagogical relationship, but rather constructing it differently. Moreover, a meta-analysis concluded that differences between remote and in-person instruction are generally minor , although outcomes vary considerably depending on the arrangements implemented. What matters is how the two modalities are designed and integrated. Remote learning can facilitate individual work, repeated access to resources and certain forms of collaboration, while in-person sessions can be reserved for activities that genuinely benefit from physical interaction.[6]

When disruption challenges routine

The blockades of French universities have forced a period of self-reflection in a country famously described as ungovernable . When everything proceeds according to the established timetable, habits take hold. We simply pick up where the previous academic year left off. Why change a system that appears to work, or, at the very least, one that rarely prompts us to question it?[7]

Unexpected events disrupt educators’ professional routines, compelling them to identify essential content, rethink their activities and, at times, abandon methods they once considered indispensable. Donald Schön describes a vital professional capacity: reflection-in-action , the ability to analyse an unforeseen situation and adjust one’s response rather than mechanically applying an established procedure. Why should educators be exempt from such a requirement? It is paradoxical to train students in critical thinking while assuming that the pedagogical frameworks in which they learn are beyond questioning.[8][9]

The reflection naturally extends to the nature of learning and the role assigned to students. Jacques Tardif suggests focusing on students’ ability to mobilise resources in complex situations , rather than merely assessing their capacity to recall information. An unsettling question follows: is the French university system genuinely preparing students to become autonomous executives, or is it fostering dependence on instructors who explain, structure, monitor and evaluate every stage of the learning process?[10]

Remote learning makes the issue particularly pressing, as it requires students to organise their own work with greater autonomy: seeking out resources independently, anticipating deadlines and developing collective strategies to understand a subject when working in groups. Yet autonomy should not mean leaving students to fend for themselves. Effective support remains essential, including through the digital communication channels and social media platforms they already use in their everyday lives.

Time for French universities to adapt

Ultimately, the issue lies in the French university system’s capacity to adapt its organisation without losing sight of its core mission. These disruptions will not be the last. Unfortunately evidence shows that periods of upheaval do not automatically lead to profound transformation . They can just as easily result in partial adaptations or even resistance and therein lies the greatest risk. Teaching methods may be changed overnight on a temporary basis, with a few adjustments made, only for the system to revert to its previous practices as soon as circumstances allow. The interlude closes, and old habits reassert themselves. Yet, as Angelo Pirrone reminds us, rethinking academic practices does not mean abandoning traditional methods , but rather recognising the diversity of learning situations.[11][12]

The COVID-19 provides a clear example. Within weeks, the French university system had to shift to remote learning. The experience could have served as a starting point for a broader reflection on pedagogical organisation. Instead familiar reflexes quickly re-emerged: classes were relocated at short notice, sometimes barely an hour before they were scheduled to take place in person; remote instruction was improvised; and institutions largely waited for business as usual to resume. It is as if the French university system, constrained by its own organisational inertia, has become accustomed to temporary adjustments without engaging in collective learning. Yet learning from a crisis entails more than simply experiencing it: institutions must draw lessons, embed them in their practices and prepare alternative responses.[13]

Organisational resilience in higher education requires moving beyond the logic of simply returning to business as usual. A resilient university system does not merely sustain its operations in the face of adversity; it learns from disruption and improves how it functions. Building such resilience requires accessible digital resources, alternative pedagogical scenarios, pre-planned assessment methods and appropriate support for both faculty and students. Crucially, flexibility must not become a euphemism for increased workloads or constant improvisation, particularly in France, where universities are already struggling under severe financial strain .[14]

One uncomfortable question therefore remains: is the system committed to in-person instruction for its pedagogical merits, or simply because it fits an organisational model it has mastered? If French universities expect their students to adapt to an uncertain, complex and turbulent world, perhaps it is time they applied the same lesson to themselves.

This article gives the views of the authors, not the position of LSE Impact or the London School of Economics. You are agreeing with our comment policy when you leave a comment.[15]