← Economy & society

The challenge of REF 2029 lies in demonstrating the capability of research environments, not just activity

Published here:

Research England recently published their final guidance for submissions to the 2029 research excellence framework. Kashan Pirzada argues that the Strategy, People and Research Environment section has the potential to drive change in the sector, but will require careful attention as to how work on research culture translates into practical capabilities.

REF 2029 has finalised how universities will be assessed on Strategy, People and Research Environment . Universities can readily list what they have in place: research centres, doctoral programmes, partnerships and researcher-development initiatives. But lists show provision. The harder question, sharpened by the final criteria, is what those structures enable researchers to do.[1]

This matters beyond the mechanics of REF. Research environments shape who gets access to time, expertise, networks and methodological support, and therefore who can turn ideas into publications, funding applications, collaborations, engagement and impact. In that sense, research environment is not simply something universities describe for assessment; it is part of the infrastructure through which research capability is distributed.

Within REF itself, Strategy, People and Research Environment (SPRE) will account for 20 per cent of the REF 2029 assessment. The SPRE guidance places considerable responsibility on institutions: the institutional-level contribution makes up 60 per cent of the SPRE score, with unit-level submissions, organised around subject-based Units of Assessment, contributing 40 per cent. The final criteria describe the purpose of SPRE as assessing how effectively institutions and units “enable, sustain and enhance” research, engagement and impact excellence. They expect narrative to be tightly coupled with evidence of effectiveness : what improved, what did not, what was learned and how that evidence shaped subsequent action. Three practical questions follow: what capability is support meant to build, who can access it, and what evidence shows that it is making a difference?[2][3]

From provision to capability

A mentoring programme shows why the first question matters. Its existence is easy to report, but its value becomes clear in less tangible ways, when researchers are better able to frame research questions, improve research design, develop proposals, respond to peer review or navigate publication.[4]

Access matters as much as provision

Access matters as much as provision because the same programme can work very differently depending on who is able to use it. Academic staff span different career stages, workload arrangements and areas of expertise, and their academic work connects to research in different ways, from disciplinary and pedagogical research to research-informed teaching. Research culture is also shaped through everyday practices in teaching and inquiry , where questioning, evidence and reflection become part of how academic work is experienced. The final framework also recognises research-enabling staff and research students as part of this wider community, making access to capability a broader institutional question.[5]

Colleagues on teaching-heavy contracts, those working part-time, and those early in their careers may find support harder to reach than colleagues who are more established. Yet the same differences can strengthen multidisciplinary work when colleagues are able to connect across disciplines. An inclusive research environment helps people at different career stages develop expertise in their fields and creates ways for that expertise to connect with others. This is where institutional ambition meets everyday practice. Importantly, the criteria recognise that gaps can exist between the two; an effective environment is one that can identify and address those gaps and their unintended consequences. A university may have excellent support on paper while access remains uneven because of workload, career stage, disciplinary location or employment pattern.

The same applies to expertise that universities already possess. Editorial experience, methodological expertise and external networks become institutional capabilities only when they are shared through mentoring, peer review, collaboration and researcher development, rather than remaining concentrated in individual CVs . Research centres can bring together multidisciplinary work and methodological specialists to strengthen research design and analysis. Partnerships can open routes to collaboration, data sharing, engagement and impact. Each connects individual researchers to the wider research community and to institutional research ambitions.[6]

The institutional challenge is therefore not only to create support, but to learn from how that support is used. Recent research involving 55 decision-makers across six UK universities suggests that institutions themselves do not routinely use research evidence when making decisions about research culture and strategy. If participation is concentrated in particular disciplines, contract types or career stages, that is itself evidence of how the research environment is functioning. SPRE can therefore become a mechanism for institutional learning rather than simply a retrospective account of activity.[7]

Evidence should show what changed

On the third question, providing evidence does not mean converting every effect into another performance measure. The REF Secretariat has stressed that SPRE is not a mechanistic exercise driven by metrics or performance indicators. The final criteria encourage quantitative evidence where appropriate, but also welcome qualitative evidence where it better supports the claim, while recognising that progress will not be uniform. What matters is connecting the claim to evidence: what changed, where progress was limited, what was learned and what happened next. Evidence might show that a mentoring programme improved research practice, that cross-unit collaborations brought disciplines together, or that editorial expertise strengthened colleagues’ peer review judgment and understanding of publishing standards. The aim is not simply to show that activities took place, but to link the evidence to the capability claimed and the difference it made.[8]

Ultimately, the strength of a research environment depends on how institutional strategy translates across units and disciplines. Formal structures such as research centres can bring expertise together, but their value depends on whether institutions connect knowledge, experience and networks across departments, disciplines and career stages in ways that researchers can use. That relationship is now part of the assessment itself: panels will look for interplay between institution- and unit-level strategy, including, where relevant, how strategy and practice influence one another in both directions. The final SPRE framework gives universities an opportunity to show how institutional strategy and unit-level practice reinforce one another: developing people, widening access to expertise and strengthening the capabilities from which research, engagement and impact can grow.

Used this way, SPRE could become more than a REF narrative: it could provide universities with a clearer account of where research capability is being built, where it remains concentrated and where institutional systems need to change. The real test, therefore, is not how much activity an institution can describe, but what its research environment enables people to do.

This article gives the views of the authors, not the position of LSE Impact or the London School of Economics. You are agreeing with our comment policy when you leave a comment.[9]