← Economy & society

New business models could help deploy clean energy technologies at scale

Published here:

During COP31 Shefali Khanna looks at “energy-as-a-service”, a business model in which customers pay for an energy service without making upfront capital investment. Using examples from Britain, America and India she argues that subsidies tied to household ownership may hold back service-based business models, and that their strongest case may lie in the flexibility they can offer the electricity system.

The Turkish presidency of COP31 has launched a “35 by 35” global electrification pledge , which aims to raise electricity’s share of global final energy consumption to 35 per cent by 2035. The International Energy Agency (IEA) estimates that today its share is around 23 per cent. Meeting this target depends on millions of households and firms adopting heat pumps, electric vehicles and electric boilers, much of which costs more upfront than what it replaces.[1][2][3]

Many governments have sought to accelerate deployment by lowering the purchase price of new equipment through grants and tax credits paid to the buyer. An alternative is a business model in which the customer does not buy the equipment but pays a provider for the service it delivers. Do subsidies paid to buyers get in the way of this alternative?

The largest “Energy-as-a-service” deals so far have involved business customers rather than households

Energy as a service (EaaS) has been described as “a business model in which customers pay for an energy service without making upfront capital investment”. The provider usually installs, owns, operates and maintains the equipment and is paid for what it delivers, unlike in the older energy service company (ESCO) model , in which the customer usually ends up owning the equipment. Providers that manage many devices together, for example by charging batteries or electric vehicles when electricity is cheap, could also lower the cost of the service .[4][5][6]

Some EaaS providers serving businesses are now raising large amounts of finance. The World Bank’s Multilateral Investment Guarantee Agency has set up a $495 million guarantee framework to help CrossBoundary Energy expand its solar, wind and battery systems for businesses in Africa. And in December 2025 Redaptive closed what it describes as the first securitisation backed by EaaS contracts.[7][8][9][10]

Offers to households have often taken a different form, in which the household owns the equipment. Several heat pump “subscriptions” offered in Britain, including those from Octopus Energy and Aira, are finance agreements, so the household owns the heat pump. And India’s PM Surya Ghar rooftop solar scheme has reached around five million households , mainly through systems the households own. One exception is Octopus Energy’s electric-vehicle offer in Britain, which leases cars to households and gives them a discount on a smart-charging tariff under which Octopus schedules the charging.[11][12]

Most economic research on energy service contracts has studied ESCOs rather than EaaS. But it suggests why such contracts may be easier to write with firms than with households. Liang Ding, Sam Aflaki and Roman Kapuscinski argue that residential contracts are harder to design because occupants’ behaviour makes savings hard to attribute. EaaS may avoid part of this problem by charging for a service that a meter records directly, such as heat delivered. But the fixed cost of writing each contract and the credit risk of each customer are likely to weigh more heavily on a contract with one household than on one with a firm.[13]

The evidence on households is strongest for rooftop solar and thin for heating

Much of the evidence on alternatives to household ownership comes from rooftop solar in the United States, where many systems are owned by a third party through a solar lease or a power purchase agreement. These arrangements need not include maintenance or flexibility, but like EaaS they let households adopt solar without paying the full upfront cost.

Studies find that these arrangements extended adoption to younger and less affluent households. In 2023, according to Berkeley Lab , third-party ownership was almost twice as common among the lowest-income adopters as among the highest-income ones. But who receives a subsidy need not be who benefits from it. Jacquelyn Pless and Arthur van Benthem estimate that about 78 per cent of California’s rebate for rooftop solar reached households that bought their systems and about 153 per cent reached households whose systems were third-party owned, meaning that the price these households paid fell by more than the rebate.[14][15][16]

For heating, a 108-home trial by Energy Systems Catapult found heat-as-a-service technically feasible but did not show it to be commercially viable, although a choice experiment with homeowners in France, Germany and Switzerland finds a willingness to pay for leasing offers that protect them against technical risk.[17][18]

Subsidy design may influence whether clean energy is sold as a product or a service

Subsidies are justified where they correct a market failure, such as an unpriced emissions externality or knowledge spillovers from early deployment. Subsidy design is only one obstacle to service contracts with households, since these contracts are small, long and difficult to enforce. But a subsidy paid to whoever owns the asset can affect which business models are tried and improved over time.

In Britain, the Boiler Upgrade Scheme, which gives households in England and Wales a £7,500 grant towards replacing a fossil-fuel boiler with a heat pump, requires the property owner to own the heat pump, and the government deferred a decision in November 2025 on allowing models in which the property owner does not own it.[19]

In India, PM Surya Ghar pays its subsidy, of up to ₹78,000 (about $830) per household in most states, directly to households that own their systems. Guidelines for routes led by energy service companies or utilities were issued only in January 2025 .[20][21]

The United States suggests that subsidy rules can also favour third-party ownership. In 2025, the US Congress ended a 30 per cent tax credit for homeowners who buy solar, while keeping the Section 48E credit , which companies that lease systems to households can claim, until 2027. In a 2026 industry survey, 55 per cent of installers said that third-party ownership had become their most-used financing route.[22][23]

Paying subsidies to providers instead would not necessarily help households, since in a concentrated market a subsidy paid to providers could end up largely as profit. Subsidies could instead be neutral about ownership, as US tax credits were until the end of 2025, when both homeowners who bought solar and companies that leased it to them could claim one. Public money may also go further if it lowers providers’ cost of capital and credit risk, through loan guarantees or payment-security funds, or if it pays for outcomes, such as heat delivered or flexibility provided, rather than for equipment.

Better evidence is needed on flexibility, subsidy design and contract terms

Most of the evidence reviewed above describes who adopts under different arrangements, rather than what those arrangements deliver. Three questions in particular remain unanswered.

First, does the business model affect how much flexibility the electricity system obtains? The IEA expects short-term flexibility needs to grow between two- and seven-fold by 2035, with the largest opportunities in electric vehicle charging, heat pumps and water heating. Where a provider controls these assets, flexibility can be written into the contract, whereas where customers own them, it has to be secured through prices or smart tariffs. The size of this difference does not appear to have been measured.[24]

Second, which subsidy design delivers more installed capacity, more quickly, for each pound or rupee of public money, a subsidy only for households that own the equipment, a subsidy that any owner can claim or no subsidy at all? A subsidy limited to household owners may slow deployment if it discourages business models that could reach more households, but by how much is not known.

Third, which contract terms make service contracts with households workable? Credit risk may be easier to manage if the contract is attached to the meter and repaid through the electricity bill. Defaults in American programmes that recover loans through the utility bill have been low . But it is unclear whether this would work in India, where some distribution companies face high levels of non-payment.[25]

On the evidence so far, the case for EaaS may rest less on widening access than on its value to the electricity system. If providers that control heat pumps, batteries and electric vehicles can shift when they draw power, these assets could support the grid rather than strain it. If so, subsidy rules that favour one form of ownership would affect not only who adopts these technologies but also how much they contribute to a flexible electricity system.

This article gives the views of the author, not the position of LSE Business Review or the London School of Economics. You are agreeing with our comment policy when you leave a comment.